A Debreceni Egyetem Állam- és Jogtudományi Karának évente kétszer megjelenő, jog- és államtudományi folyóirata. Alapítva a debreceni jogászképzés újraindításának 15. évében. Folyóiratunkat az MTA Állam- és Jogtudományi Bizottsága 2013-ban „A” kategóriába sorolta, melyet a 2023-as felülvizsgálat során is fenntartott.

Az online és nyomtatott kiadásban is megjelenő lap magyar nyelvű lapszámaiba folyamatosan lehet benyújtani a kéziratokat. Az online verzió a papír alapú lapszámtól független, így az évi két lapszámba rendezett tanulmányok megjelenésére már a lektorálást követően sor kerülhet. Határidő: folyamatos.

Szerkesztőségünk címe: profuturo@law.unideb.hu.

Vol. 15 No. 2 (2025) Current Issue

Published December 30, 2025

##issue.tableOfContents##

Focus

  • The Justifyability and Current Status of Animal Legal Personhood
    Views:
    86

    This paper is structured around three central questions: (1) Can animals be legal persons? (2) How is legal personhood related to the recognition of rights? (3) How do these two questions relate to effective animal protection? The paper first outlines the positions of the main proponents of well-known theories of rights – namely, the will-based and interest-based theories – to examine more closely whether legal personhood for animals can be justified. Turning to the second question, while the recognition of legal personhood is traditionally considered a prerequisite for the recognition of rights, this text questions that assumption at one point. Various models of animal protection are then presented, each addressing the purpose of granting rights to animals. Although the paper does not avoid the difficulties that hinder the recognition of legal personhood and substantive rights, it concludes that the effectiveness of animal protection is closely linked to the recognition of legal personhood.

  • The Future of Animal Cruelty in the Context of Changing Public Morals
    Views:
    200

    Thanks to the unstoppable rise of social media and other online communication channels, acts of animal cruelty and deficiencies in animal husbandry culture are now receiving increasing publicity. The research found that the growing interest in animal welfare reflects a broader shift in social attitudes. Whether we examine the assessment of animal cruelty at the level of morality or law, we see a rapidly and continuously changing process that is internally coherent. The objective of this study is based on this finding. First, by highlighting the depth of the relationship between morality and law, it demonstrates that these two institutions are inseparable and mutually influential. The following part of the study describes the development and current system of moral and legal norms relating to animal cruelty, and finally, through de lege ferenda proposals, it aims to provoke thought and initiate debate regarding the further development of the system.

  • The Intersection of Animal Keeping and Environmental Harm
    Views:
    133

    Pet ownership, particularly the keeping of exotic birds, is becoming increasingly popular. However, we still know surprisingly little about certain segments of animal keepers. This study aims to profile a distinct group within this community: collectors. Based on 20 interviews conducted using the snowball sampling method, the research highlights the characteristics of these individuals. The findings suggest that breeding may provide a sustainable alternative to meet the demand for live specimens of protected species and could also serve as a foundation for species reintroduction and repopulation programmes. However, due to the increasingly stringent legal framework, the boundaries between legal and illegal keeping practices are becoming more blurred.

Articles

  • Candidate Nomination in Hungary: Regulation and Data Protection Law Implications
    Views:
    184

    The study examines the data-protection implications inherent in the domestic candidate nomination system. In Hungary, the nomination of a candidate for election is based on the legal mechanism of collecting voters’ ‘recommendations’, a process that necessarily involves the processing of their personal data. This gives rise to several data-protection dilemmas, the most significant of which are: (a) whether a voter’s recommendation constitutes or reveals a ‘political opinion’; (b) the role, under data-protection law, of those collecting recommendations; (c) the lawful duration of the collection process; and (d) whether voters may be informed of, or ascertain, that their personal data appear on a recommendation sheet. The analysis is grounded in a dogmatic legal method: it reviews and evaluates both domestic and European legal sources, the official positions adopted by supervisory authorities, and the pertinent academic literature. The study demonstrates that the development of the regulatory framework reflects the gradual incorporation of data-protection safeguards; nevertheless, in several areas it continues to employ regulatory solutions that depart from, and in certain respects even contradict, the underlying logic of data-protection law.

  • From Accusation to Proof: The Right to a Fair Trial in the Light of Digital Evidence
    Views:
    30

    The aim of this study is to examine whether digital evidence, which plays an increasingly prominent role in criminal proceedings, complies with one of the most fundamental constitutional guarantees of the administration of justice: the right to a fair trial. More specifically, the study seeks to determine whether, within the framework of the evidentiary process, the accused and the defence are given a genuine opportunity to obtain full access to and examine evidence in digital form in a manner that ensures that the right to a fair trial is not infringed. To this end, I shall first outline the concept of electronic data as a newly applied means of evidence in Hungarian procedural law. I shall then discuss the substance of the right to a fair trial and the origins of this fundamental principle, before comparing these with the specific characteristics of digital evidence and the rules of evidence. Throughout this work, where relevant, I have also cited court rulings from both Hungary and other jurisdictions, drawing primarily on decisions of the European Court of Human Rights. Upon completion of my work, I will summarise the points made and provide an answer to the question posed above.

Legal Practice

  • Ex Ante and Ex Post Competition Law Models in the Digital Economy: A Comparative Analysis of EU and US Regulation
    Views:
    147

    The rise of digitalisation, network externalities, and data as novel sources of competitive advantage has fundamentally challenged traditional doctrines of competition law. With the adoption of the Digital Markets Act (DMA) and the Digital Services Act (DSA), the European Union has established an ex ante, preventive regulatory paradigm designed, among other aims, to avert market distortions caused by gatekeeper platforms. By contrast, the United States continues to rely primarily on ex post enforcement, precedent-based adjudication, and judicial processes in governing digital service markets. The divergence between these two models reflects deeper economic-philosophical and legal-policy differences; however, an emerging tendency towards convergence can be observed in their shared recognition of the democratic and geopolitical significance of digital markets. The evolution of competition law in recent decades has been profoundly shaped by digital corporations, which have redefined the conceptual boundaries of global market structures. A comprehensive understanding of contemporary legal practice and regulatory developments therefore requires a systematic examination of the theoretical divergences and convergences, and of the underlying explanatory factors shaping both regimes.

  • Constitutional Issues of Slovak Land Transaction Regulations: Decision 20/2014 of the Slovak Constitutional Court on the Constitutionality of Certain Provisions of the Act on Land Acquisition
    Views:
    129

    In this study, we analyse in detail Decision 20/2014 of the Slovak Constitutional Court, which examined the constitutionality of certain provisions of the Act on Land Acquisition. In this decision, the Constitutional Court addressed the constitutionality of the rules governing the transfer of ownership of agricultural land by sale. In addition to analysing the Constitutional Court's decision, the study discusses the background to the initiation of the Constitutional Court proceedings, the aftermath of the Court's decision, and the 2017 amendment to the Slovak Constitution, which is closely related to the topic under review.

Law & Politics

  • Are Charter Cities Innovation Theatres or Threats to State Sovereignty? The Example of Próspera in Honduras
    Views:
    66

    In Honduras, the corrupt elite that came to power after the 2009 military coup allowed foreign investors to create special economic zones in the country as part of a new economic stimulus package. These zones were allowed to create their own private legal framework, which Tegucigalpa hoped would improve the country’s economic situation. The most famous ZEDE implemented has been Próspera, which is mainly backed by US venture capital managers. After the Honduran legal framework on ZEDEs was repealed in 2024, a certain amount of uncertainty arose, as although investments are protected for 10, or 50 years, the hostile social and political environment might pose a significant obstacle to their continued operation.