Peer Evaluation Sheet

 

Title of the article submitted for evaluation
Evaluation
Relevance of the topic x of 5 points
Level of elaboration x of 5 points
Consistent application of research methods x of 5 points
Structural coherence x of 5 points
Knowledge of relevant literature x of 5 points
Language and style x of 5 points
Novelty of result x of 5 points
Observance of formal requirements x of 5 points
Total x of 40 points

Reviewer’s remark in the language of the article:

a) I support the publication of the article without alterations

b) I support the publication of the article with minor alterations

c) I support the publication of the article with major changes and a second review

d) I do not support the publication of the article

The last three points must be justified.

Download the evaluation sheet