Reviewer’s Evaluation Form

 

Title of the article Evaluation
Relevance of the topic out of 5 points
Development of the content out of 5 points
Consistent application of the methodology out of 5 points
Structural coherence out of 5 points
Knowledge of the literature out of 5 points
Language and style out of 5 points
Originality of the results out of 5 points
Compliance with formal requirements out of 5 points
Total out of 40 points

Reviewer’s comments in the language of the work:

a) I recommend publication without revisions

b) I recommend publication with minor revisions

c) I recommend publication with major revisions and a second review

d) I do not recommend publication

In the latter three cases, justification is required.

Download the Reviewer's Evaluation Form